日本語

ELI5

Explain it like I’m five
In his heart,he probablysaid it.

それでも地球は動いている(それでもちきゅうはうごいている)Did Galileo really say “And yet it moves”?

日本語English

In Japaneseそれでも地球は動いている · soredemo chikyū wa ugoite iru
Word for word: “Even so, the Earth is moving”

In one line“And yet it moves” is said to be what Galileo muttered after his church trial. It is not in the records of the time and is thought to be a later invention.

“And yet it moves.” Galileo Galilei taught that the Earth goes around the Sun. In 1633 a church court made him take back his idea. Afterward, the story goes, he quietly muttered these words. But they do not appear in the court records, or in the notes of anyone who was there. The words spread in a book more than 100 years after the trial. Still, it is a pretty safe bet that Galileo thought them in his heart.

Common mix-upThere is no record of him saying it at the trial. The story spread much later.
Words to know / 単語メモ
court
裁判
take back
(説を)捨てる
mutter
つぶやく
trial
裁判
safe bet
まちがいないこと

Your turn

Did you know this word?

Tap to see what everyone said.

SharePostLINE

Related words

“It is not the strongest that survives”Q. Did Darwin write it?
A. It is not in Darwin’s books. It is a later person’s own summary of t…
“If you can’t explain it to a six year old”Q. Did Einstein say it?
A. It has not been shown to be Einstein’s words. It is not found in his…
“Insanity is doing the same thing over and over”“Insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results” is a famous…“The opposite of love is not hate, it’s indifference”Q. Did Mother Teresa say it?
A. It has not been shown to be Mother Teresa’s words. An early record i…
“A bad law is still the law”Q. Did Socrates say it?
A. It is not a recorded saying of Socrates. People linked it to him lat…
“Genius is one percent inspiration, ninety-nine percent perspiration”“Genius is one percent inspiration, ninety-nine percent perspiration” is a line by the inven…“Elementary, my dear Watson”“Elementary, my dear Watson” is known as Sherlock Holmes’s catchphrase. It does not appear i…His reallast wordswere likely different.“Et tu, Brute?”“Et tu, Brute?” means “You too, Brutus?” It is famous as what Julius Caesar said in ancient Rome when he was killed. He saw that Brutus, a man he trusted, had j…“Live as if you were to die tomorrow”“People are the castle”Q. Did Shingen write it?
A. It has not been shown that Shingen wrote it himself. It appears in a…
The real one:it had alreadyhappened.“Houston, we have a problem”“Houston, we have a problem.” This is famous as what the astronauts told Mission Control in 1970. Apollo 13 was on its way to the Moon when an accident struck. …“Standing on the shoulders of giants”Q. Did Newton invent the phrase?
A. Newton was not the first to say it. Scholars in the 12th century alr…